You know, I still can't figure out why HPD boss Robert Clarke was in Vegas' last week. Whatever the reason, it garnered a ton of media attention and probably gave the IRL brass headaches galore. Why?
It's no secret that, unlike Toyota's departure from CART in 2002, Honda was still trying to convince CART leaders not to play "follow-the-leader" politics and give in to TRD's efforts at foisting on CART an IRL-style engine program. When they failed, they also followed TRD(Toyota Racing Development) over to the Indy Racing League, albeit late to the dance.
For HPD, 2003 wasn't pretty. Honda won just two races in 2003(Tony Kanaan at Phoenix, Bryan Herta at Kansas) to Chevy's three and Toyota's 11 wins. In addition, only two HPD drivers(Kanaan-4th, Kenny Brack-9th) finished in the top-10. When they caught up to TRD and the "bow-tie" brigade(Chevy).....
Since Homestead 2004, HPD has 25 wins, Toyota 6 wins and Chevy just 1 win, with Honda's factory teams, Andretti-Green Racing and Rahal-Letterman Racing leading the charge. However, with TRD and Chevy set to depart the IRL, Honda faces the question, What shall we do? HPD(and I've said this before)
craves competition, and will do anything possible to find competition; hence, Clarke's visit to Vegas. But what should ChampCar do about this?
That is a very difficult question. Without question, a key ingredient to ChampCar's revival/resurgence has been the adoption of a spec-engine, the Ford-Cosworth XFE-2 2.65L turbo engine, that all teams are required to use. Coupled with a near-spec Lola B0/02 chassis, and CC has a nearly-even playing field. The key is nearly even. Ask yourself this--Why is Newman-Haas Racing, using the same equipment Forsythe, RuSport, PKV and others have, doing so much better than they are? The answer...they have the best race engineers in CC(Craig Hampson and Rocky Rockelin), the best crews and two of the better drivers(Bourdais and Servia) in the series. They also, ironically, have the most resources to spend(which probably irritates Messrs. Forsythe, Kalkhoven and Gentilozzi), something that would be negated if the other teams would spend more money on their teams. And there lies one of the problems that, ultimately, felled CART. Remember in one of my earliest commentaries I mentioned that CART had 4 engines makes(Mercedes-Ilmor, Honda, Toyota and Ford-Cosworth) back in the late 1990s'? While it was all well and good that it was so, the flip side was that costs began spiriling upwards at an increasingly scary rate as the engine cos. spent, spent and
spent untowards amts. of money trying to better the competition(which is starting to catch up to the IRL

).
So, what would a Honda return do for ChampCar? Well, on the positive side, look at all the collateral benefits, in terms of sponsor-partnerships that Honda has in the IRL(w/cos. such as Pioneer, Motorola, Panasonic, etc.) and all the advertising money that HPD spends during the year(there's at least two of their ads in USA Today every week, at a minimum). Th eproblem, though, is as I stated above. Honda spends its' money
to win, just as TRD, Ford Racing, Cosworth, etc. do. If Honda were to return, those engine costs would go up. And eventually CC would have to do one of two things:1--either accept a yr.-by-yr. "caste" system of one side doing better than the other, or 2--force HPD and FC to use the same spec-setup on their engines. Neither sounds appealing at the moment.
In the final analysis, I would argue that the biggest challenge facing
both the ChampCar World Series and the Indy Racing League is this--they should figure out how to bring their car counts up from the current levels to a larger no., say 22-24 at least. Do this, and even if their isn't reunification, at least both will be secure, especially ChampCar.