News On F1 Forums - Talk Formula 1

Julian Mayo wrote:This is my call because, while there are so many uncertainties about reliability etc in the pre-season
, I believe the regs favour the B runners. Mark is a known cracker of a qualifier, a "good authority" tells me that the new 7 speed "seamless change" gearbox problems are solved ( at least with 7 as against last years 6 speeder the Bloody Williams should get off the line this season)The Cosworth will be one of, if not the most powerful early on. Toyota have Donkey's years of tradition in producing bullet proof engines,but Ralf will be too much of a burden for them to take 1st.

Well, well, well.

I should retitle this forum: The Boulderdash F1 Game - awards for the people that can best justify the most incorrect pre-season tips!!

Julian . . . I hope your right on Williams. The thing I most hope for, is that there are more than two teams with cars good enough for race wins.

But can toyota be one of them? Engine realibility is one thing, but Toyota are yet to show us they can do pace AND reliability. I cant see them taking a championship or many race wins without lots of luck or a superb driver. They are a safe team. They will be there somewhere, but like last year, they will be that team in the top 8 of the grid that every other team doesnt want to get stuck behind.

Julian Mayo wrote:because of the 2006 Regs my predictions are
Manchamp:
Toyota
Williams
Renault
Ferrari
Honda
Mclaren
Sauber
Redbull
.................
Drivers
Webber
Trulli
Alonso
Nico/Ralf tied
Fisi
Nick
Barrichello
JPM/Schuey tied
DC
JV
The Iceman will be red with Fury, and will wear out shoes walking back to the pits. He is a brilliant driver, but exposes any AND every weakness a car has

......


( anyone who thinks Fisi can't drive should watch a slo-mo of Spa last year...it IS possible to "drift" a modern F1 car

.....

Next season(2007)......?
...

MIA Renault.

Pardon me Julian but I have an observation or 3 to make.

The first one is to do with maths
In your latest predictions you have Nico and Ralf tied and Toyota winning the constrcutors. This means that Trulli will have more points than Webber
Emotions only earn Webber virtual points that don't count

Second, on the 2nd of February you had:

Constructors.
McLaren
Williams
Ferrari
Renault
Toyota
Sauber
RedBull
The rest

Drivers
JPM
Webber
Kimi
Schuey
Nico
Fisi
Alonso
Trulli
Heidfield
The rest


and just a mere 3 days later you have

Manchamp:
Toyota
Williams
Renault
Ferrari
Honda
Mclaren
Sauber
Redbull
.................
Drivers
Webber
Trulli
Alonso
Nico/Ralf tied
Fisi
Nick
Barrichello
JPM/Schuey tied
DC
JV



That was a major shuffle

During those 3 days I think nothing has changed. Mercedes were still blowing engines, Williams were still having serious problems, Bridgestone were still scratching their heads and Renault were still setting lap records.

Third, I am not sure why you insist on believing those trashy sites that are desperately trying to keep spreading rumours about Renault. The President of Renault, the one who many are claiming will pull the plug has clearly stated that they will be in F1. What isn't clear is beyond 2007 and that is the same for all the manufacturers. No one really knows what will happen in 2008 including those trashy sites who just make up stories when there is nothing interesting.
Oh and just a note on the can drive Fisi, remember he also crashed at Spa last year and gave away the Japanese Grand Prix to Kimi (just imagine if it was Alonso who had passed him what would have Kapel said ).

Oh and I see your respect for McLaren grows in 2007. Interesting

What I do know about Renault is that they have a habit of coming and going, they are losing their major sponsor, and Alonso at the end of the season, so I have a question mark about their desire to continue. Just a question mark. Nothing more. The rest of that post was, again, just for fun. Past experience has taught me that we will know little til the first two races are done and done.
And remember, one person's trash is another person's treasure.

Julian Mayo wrote:What I do know about Renault is that they have a habit of coming and going, they are losing their major sponsor, and Alonso at the end of the season, so I have a question mark about their desire to continue. Just a question mark. Nothing more. The rest of that post was, again, just for fun. Past experience has taught me that we will know little til the first two races are done and done.
And remember, one person's trash is another person's treasure.

Of course it is for fun, Webber or Toyota winning the titles is beyond miraculous and will at least require Renault pull out in 2006

Julian, from the pace of the Renault so far I think you can conclude that they are at least title contenders regardless what hat you are wearing. Fighting for the title means positive coverage and no car company would say no to that.
Their major sponsor was already leaving, it was well known unless you only read the headlines. Same with BAT but somehow that isn't a problem for Honda.
Yes Alonso is leaving but I suspect that if Alonso asked for more money they wouldn't have paid so perhaps the move happened a few months earlier than normal. They have Kovalainen and if you notice his times from testing and his results from GP2, he is as highly rated as Nico. (and they both have Finn blood )
All is well at Renault as long as mad max goes away and takes all his stupid ideas with him.

But tell me , how is Webber going to win the title if Nico and Ralf are tied and Toyota win the constructors. I still can't figure that one out

I will be somewhat surprised if Alonso does not win the title.
The tie remains yours to unravel

JayVee wrote: But tell me , how is Webber going to win the title if Nico and Ralf are tied and Toyota win the constructors. I still can't figure that one out

Its basic elementary school maths... 1+1= 3 simple.

<T-K> wrote:

JayVee wrote: But tell me , how is Webber going to win the title if Nico and Ralf are tied and Toyota win the constructors. I still can't figure that one out

Its basic elementary school maths... 1+1= 3 simple.

Don't forget to carry the .05, divide by the Max Factor, and carry the minor points each score.....simple really

OK, I will resolve the Dilemma.......partially. Max is going to suspend some teams for some time. QED

Julian Mayo wrote:

<T-K> wrote:

JayVee wrote: But tell me , how is Webber going to win the title if Nico and Ralf are tied and Toyota win the constructors. I still can't figure that one out

Its basic elementary school maths... 1+1= 3 simple.

Don't forget to carry the .05, divide by the Max Factor, and carry the minor points each score.....simple really

Very good......that earns you one free drink at the bar.....here, take this hand drawn token i made the other day.....

Who can tell me what JayVee does for a living? (other than post to this forum)

It just seems weird to me that a woman (no insult intended or implied) can be so logical that I cant argue!!
Unfortunately it seems like Renault ARE going to be the team to beat again this season with all the rest once again trying to play catch up.

Constructors:

renault
ferrari
honda
toyota
williams
red bull
mclaren
sauber bmw

Drivers
alonso
schumacher (m)
barrichello
Fisi
button
DC
webber

As good a guess as any I say!!

Cheers

GhoGho wrote:Who can tell me what JayVee does for a living? (other than post to this forum)

It just seems weird to me that a woman (no insult intended or implied) can be so logical that I cant argue!!

I work in IT (logical again!!)

A single parent with 2 kids can hardly afford to be illogical

But most importantly, with all the illogic you see here about W & W one has to be logical

But you have hammered McLaren. Graham and Jim won't be happy at all
And BMW Sauber will surprise a few. Afterall a World Champ is driving for them (logical )

Julian Mayo wrote:OK, I will resolve the Dilemma.......partially. Max is going to suspend some teams for some time. QED

So Max will suspend Williams and Webber will go to Renault. I see

But Williams signed Concorde, Max can't suspend them

There is a much easier way to explain it Julian

Max IS God.

Rah, Lloyd and at one stage Julian, were tipping top 2 in the constructors for Toyota. . . I am wondering how long it will take for them to admit how poor a prediction that was

In the last few tests we have seen some good times by Renault and Honda. Some good times from Mclaren, in between maintenance work.

Ok times from Williams and the team they would love to beat the most, BMW . . .

but where the heck is Toyota??

I am refining my tips and providing reasons for why Toyota will drop off the pace in 06: Ralf is suffering from arthritis mid-corner and Trulli is losing time as he tries to flick those locks out of his eyes.

BlinkyBill,

Julian predicts Toyota will WIN the constructors

Toyota and McLaren will go backwards this year. Toyota due to the tyres, McLaren due to their engines.

Williams will not improve by much and it will be an interesting fight with BMW.